One thing that strikes me in games is I can fight tough enemies until they are almost dead but they still fight and deal damage exactly the same as they did at 100% health. Ok that makes some sense with guns, although their accuracy should go down. But it doesn’t make sense for physical attacks.
Does anyone know of any games that reduce physical damage dealt based on health? And more importantly, does it work and is it fun?
Boxing games have this sort of mechanic in them. I havent played one since the xbox 360 though so I dont know how fun they are.
I didnt find it very fun. It felt like the superior skilled player just starts winning and then the win snowballs. You couldn’t compete at full strength you arent making a comeback.
I bet it would be fun with incredibly skilled opponents. And it is kinda fun to be the onr doing the steamrolling and showboating around, but theres no sport in that.
Yes! Check out Kenshi. Its damage system works differently for robots than for humans, but it involves bleeding, bandaging, individual healthbards for each limb, etc. Also, debuffs occur as limbs get more damaged, including difficulty blocking amd aiming. Also you can lose limbs, and prosthetics use the robot healing system (including wear over time!) and have different stats.
In games like MechWarrior and Elite Dangerous (and other related games in similar simulation type categories), weapons can be shot/disabled/broken, which means the opponent cannot attack with those particular weapons until they are repaired or until they respawn, depending on the game and game mode.
I’m not current, but I would bet Dwarf Fortress would be such a game. Keep in mind, though, that this would also apply to your side.
If I recall correctly in Star Wars: Republic Commando you can shoot parts like arms and legs off the super battle droids which limits the attacks they can do.
But also the super battle droids sucked and had too much health because I remember I hated their dispensers lol
The first thing that comes to my head is Rock Em’ Sock Em’ Robots Arena, a PS1 robot fighting game. There are overall health bars for each robot like you would expect for most fighting games, but there is also a system for tracking damage to specific parts. Right arm, left arm, torso, head, and legs. If you focus damage to one part specifically, it is possible to disable or remove that part. If you manage to disable your opponent’s head, it is an automatic victory. If you disable an arm, the arm falls off and the opponent can no longer use it or its abilities. If you disable a part and win the match, you get to keep that part and can use it in your own robot (you can also use currency to buy these parts).
The problem from a gameplay perspective is that it’s snowbally. You can start off with a relatively even, challenging match, but once you knock off an arm the match gets really easy. In this case, they fixed it by making it pretty difficult to do. You really need to focus on the specific part you want to knock off or else you will just knock the opponent out and win the match.
Another example is the Banner Saga series. They have a system for both armor and health, where the more health a character has the more damage they do. It makes for a bunch of interesting strategic decisions around party composition, itemization, positioning, and ability usage. It also makes the battles more snowball-y. In this case I would say it is a good thing becsuse it makes the matches go faster and the games are designed around the mechanic.
Civ 5 units?
In Dark Souls, the Boss Sif (a giant dog with a sword) will start limping and attack less often when he’s near death. This isn’t to make the fight more realistic, but is a mechanic to make the player sad.
And to twist the knife even further, if you do the DLC (which takes place in the past and has you save her life at one point) before fighting Sif, she’ll recognize you and whine and howl mournfully before (regretfully) grabbing her sword to fight you.
(The context behind the fight is that she’s protecting her master Artorias’ grave a la Hachiko, but you need an item that was buried with him to save the world from falling into Darkness.)
I don’t play such difficult games anymore but if I did and got to this, it’d be game over. Especially if I’d done the DLC first.
What kinda sick and twisted shit is this bruh, wtf
You’re not wrong about Sif, but there’s actually a lot of Soulsborne enemies that do more damage, get extra attacks, etc, when their health is low. Mostly bosses…
In Kingdom Come: Deliverance (1 and 2) being injured limits your stamina which prevents you from attacking as many times in a row. This applies to both the player and to enemies. These games also only have a limited healing system, only restoring health over time and not being able to use healing items in active combat, which makes it more important to plan ahead and be prepared. I think this works well as making a mistake punishes you by making it easy to get overwhelmed, even once you get to a higher level and have good gear. It also rewards slower play as putting an arrow or three into a group of enemies before they get to you gives you a huge advantage, especially if you are outnumbered.
It might not be the kind of game you’re looking for, but in Civ 6 units attack less effectively when they’re damaged.
Even as far back as Civ 2 units fought at reduced strength if they were tired (had less than one movement point).
I played a LOT of Civ 2 through 5 but I’m not sure I ever realized that.
Age of Wonders does something similar. Units you buy are often entire squads. As health decreases, members die, reducing damage. It can give a mechanical difference between a single-creature unit and a squad with similar base stats since the single unit doesn’t weaken.
A lot of strategy games similarly clump units to reduce controlled elements. The real-time ones such as Total War and Dawn of War seem to track the squad members health individually though. Heroes of Might and Magic, a turn-based game, does a weird hybrid where it calls them out as individual units but it treats them as a large health pool and kills them percentile-wise.
In all of these examples, the creatures aren’t weakening, the group is weakening as sub-units die.
Vanquish has several enemies like that. You can hit them in the legs/arms/guns to progressively cripple them, reducing their HP and making them easier to kill.
I really loved that game, had a unique feeling to it.
fallout 4 has certain enemies become practically useless if they take enough limb damage. feral ghouls could lose both arms and be inneffective at dealing any significant damage, or lose their legs and very slowly crawl around. gotta watch out for assaultrons though, even when they are crawling on the ground they can still get you good, but they are pretty much sitting ducks
New vegas and 3 are also like that.
dart gun vs deathclaw and deathclaw isnt winning 🤣
But each individual part is again like OP describes: doesn’t matter if a part is at 100 or 1 %, it only changes at 0 to nonfunctional. (At least in New Vegas and Fallout 3 it was like that, never played 4)
you should give 4 a shot someday, its really fun. more like mass effect than traditional fallout dialogue, but still fun
Bit different, but: check out the old PlayStation game ‘Bushido Blade’: it’s a ‘realistic’ samurai game where one slash with a weapon can kill. It has both a one-on-one fighting mode, and a beat-em-up adventure mode.
I’ve also heard of and seen more-modern sword fighting games with the same approach, but don’t remember the titles.
That looks pretty cool!
There’s also ‘Bushido Blade 2’. And apparently the same studio also made ‘Kengo: Master of Bushido’ for PS2 in the same vein, but it received only middling reviews. Maybe ‘Sword of the Samurai’ aka ‘Kengo 2’ is better, but idk anything about its mechanics.
Came here to say Bushido Blade, but it should be mentioned that non-fatal hits will cripple the limb they strike, and your fighter can end up crawling around unable to attack if everything’s been struck but a deathblow.
Frankly I didn’t remember if this was the case, much less whether it applied to the enemies too. ‘Deus Ex’ works similarly when it comes to the player, in that Denton might find themself crawling on the floor if their legs are shot to shit (and then standing up for a cutscene like nothing happened) — but likewise I’m not sure if it’s the same deal for the enemies.
First one that comes to mind is that monsters in Monster Hunter games get tired and eventually start limping. But that’s more about showing the damage and fatigue in games that used to not have health bars for fights that could take half an hour.
There is more to it than just showing damage and fatigue. The moves they perform also change. I recall fighting a Lagombi and as the fight progressed more of his moves were full-body, until he was near death and he was too tired to swipe at me and instead just tried body slams… unable to stand back up when he missed.
This is somewhat inaccurate.
Monsters who are low on health tend to enrage more frequently, making them deal more damage and be more aggessive. My general understanding of the game might be skewed toward G/Master rank, but my gauge for when a monster is near death is when it starts enraging almost constantly.
The mechanic you are citing is a thing, but it isnt strictly related to health. There is basically a stamina or energy system which causes them to go on a form of cooldown, the polar opposite of enraging. This state is completely negated if they enrage and they cannot enter this state while enraged.
I would believe there is a relationship with this mechanic to health, as it feels as if when enemies that dont enrage very easily at low health seem to enter this state more easily, but it could also be an esoteric system where they can only regain partially while they are engaged in a fight. Monster Hunter has long been opaque about such things, and you would need to seek this info out to even know it exists.
There is also a mechanic with blunt weapons (and special cases like Punishing Draw skill. Generally anything that can apply KO to the head) that can either force this state similarly to applying status, i believe, referred to as Fatigue, though it may vary by game and in some cases deal damage to their stamina.
I mostly played older games, and at least in those, most monsters start limping when they’ve received a bit more damage than needed to capture them. There are some that rage a lot and basically don’t have time for limping around, and some that have their own special behavior instead like playing dead. But as a general rule I’d beat up the monster until it starts limping out of the zone and then try to capture it. So there it’s definitely health based.
Punishing Draw is called Punish Draw before World so we’re probably thinking of fundamentally different gameplay. Exhausting monster stamina is a thing in either though as far as I know. The mechanic I remember is building up exhaust status (not just through skills, any blunt attacks do), and once a threshold is hit the monster flinches and loses a bunch of stamina. When it’s out of stamina it becomes slower and many start to look for food to recover stamina. So that kind of also fits the original question if we consider damaging stamina to be similar to damaging health. Although they can recover stamina much more easily than health, by eating or going into rage.
I should have mentioned the whole thing with cutting off parts too since some monsters do lose attacks when you cut off specific parts. And they don’t recover those at all. Like tail slams go away when the tail is gone and some others. But they never took that very far IMHO, can’t cut off the legs for example.
It’s partially that and partially the limb break system. Every subpart of a monster has its own health bar (there are modded overlays to show these), and when you deplete it that part will “break” with various effects such as limping, losing moves, or dropping extra monster parts. Or pissing the monster off, because Capcom are sadistic that way.
The weird thing is that limbs quickly recover and you can break them multiple times. I think it gets easier each time they break so it’s still worth focusing on a single spot, but you can’t permanently cripple most targets outside of maybe cutting off a tail.
I guess games like Soul Nomad or Advance Wars where you direct groups rather than individuals - units lose strength as individual members are taken out.




