• 0 Posts
  • 75 Comments
Joined 22 days ago
cake
Cake day: October 25th, 2026

help-circle









  • Dude, just stop with the colonial apologia.

    People don’t really hate the English other than when they begin to justify their colonial atrocities.

    The colonialism we did with a navy that was about 20% Irish and an army that was about 30% Irish? Ireland hardly innocent on that front.

    The oppressed are coerced into the military all the time. The shtick is to make their living conditions so horrible, their chances of employment so shit that they have no other choice other than to join the military that provides them with the only reprieve.

    Look to Russia with the buryats and other marginal groups for an example that’s not UK.

    You should also know the Irish were treated as second class citizens even when they were allowed into the military.

    Scotland willing got into the union.





  • I am not sure. I’ve never given it a concrete thought. Communism as a whole is very nebulous. I particularly like the socialist aspects and the welfare for all goals of communism. I like the dream of not having to work to survive.

    But I do not like the planned economy aspect of it. I haven’t seen anyone do planned economies well. This includes non communist countries that tried it. There’s something to say about how it is impossible to create a complex web of plans that accurately and adequately account for humanity’s ever-changing needs and wants. But economics is fairly complex and I have little authority over the subject matter to say anything with confidence.

    Basically - Freemarket, multi-socialist-only party system, with four strong pillars of democracy acting as checks and balances, with welfare for all.

    I don’t identify as a communist in the conventional sense or any other particular label per say. But I do lean left.



  • Not to mention it’s really NOT up for discussion/change at the best of times. So it seems we’re just locked into this slow moving system until it breaks down too much, and the cracks are showing as corporations get bigger and bigger.

    I wish people smarter than me would have an answer to this. At times I just want to hide in a hole and forget the world exists.

    Oh well, maybe someone will release a meaningful patch soon.

    Amen.




  • To be fair parties themselves aren’t monoliths. I like Hu jintao’s politics a lot more than I like Xi pings. Factionalist abound. But as far I’ve seen with any communist state, they’ve always banned other parties defacto or dejure and they usually did that in the initial years of the state.

    USSR, PRC, PRV, DPRK.

    Having multiple parties allows for two important things: accountability and representation. Despite me disagreeing with someone’s politics I’d still want them to have some sort of representation. But it’s accountability that matters more to me.

    The aforementioned governments do have accountability in whether the keys of power and people support them or not. But it’s a far less direct form than in an actual democracy and usually very proportionally disbalanced in the favor of the keys (ministers, army, or corporations).

    Unions are good, but not enough in my opinion. But this is from my own rudimentary understanding of how it.


  • so like, whilst I don’t like Tankies AT ALL (they all demand your read a specific 1000 book list before even having a discussion)… I do think anti-communists are also annoying and often under cooked/biased on historical facts.

    I agree.

    …Vietnam also has a system of Market Socialism, they’ve just almost resolved homelessness and have no housing crisis because they have a land redistribution system for anyone who wants to go into farming.

    Always assumed they did what china did. They realized that the tool to stay in power was stability and growth, so they incentivized development on the local and national level for climbing the party ladder and good boy points. But it’s nice to see them actually follow through with the ideals as well.

    In short - in comes across as reactionary (rather than thoughtful/legitmate).

    I understand how that can be tiring. I’ve stopped talking to anyone who purports any fascist or anti-socialist ideals. They will never listen. They are too comfortable with the power they hold to reconsider. On lemmy, I have come across far too many tankies who confuse me to no end. They come off as religious nuts who pretend to like the same ideals I do. They are in my opinion just as worse as the anti-communists.

    I don’t want to be associated with them. And I think the political spectrum is far too complicated to neatly divide people into simple categories. But it’s easier to do and who has the time to actually get to know strangers online. So, as a rule, I am against any tankie or fascist.