This, so much this. It was the exact same answer I got when I criticized that Gnome somehow managed to screw up screen mirroring - it is impossible to mirror two out of multiple screens, either you mirror all of them or none of them. Such a fundamentally basic feature we already had 20+ years ago, and they designed it away.
Or wallpapers. Guess how you set different wallpapers for different screens. …you can’t.
I don’t know what’s up with Gnome or why they are like this, but the way they caused a whole new DE again (Cosmic) and KDE outright leaving them in the dust they are on the best way towards obscurity.
I don’t know what’s up with Gnome or why they are like this, but the way they caused a whole new DE again (Cosmic) and KDE outright leaving them in the dust they are on the best way towards obscurity.
If you think about Gnome in terms of it targeting some corporate client who cares a whole lot about screen lock, permissions, authentication against some corporate backend, etc, and not at all about a power user running around on their own, then that is one way that can explain why they do what they do. As an example it would be great for a business that needed something one step above a kiosk (maybe like a call center?) I’d love to walk into a DMV or bank and see all the computers running Gnome with a custom app that does all the personal information. That’d be way better than seeing someone flip tabs from their facebook to handle some financial transaction with Windows/Chrome.
The terminal is pretty nice with fonts and scaling, etc, but I don’t know how people use Gnome without the extensions to add back real menus and a program toolbar.
In my experience (admittedly a couple years back) Gnome is horrible for kiosk-style systems. There’s little to no builtin support for basic requirements like hiding the top bar while in non-fullscreen-mode. While there are some plugins, the scripting API is unstable, so plugins might break with any update.
I’d have far more confidence choosing KDE, though a more usecase-specific DM is better.
I use GNOME because for me KDE somehow always surfaces the small little annoying bugs (at least on my hardware). But I try every couple of years hoping I can finally switch.
Yeah I’ve definitely had a buggier experience on kde than gnome. My only gnome “bugs” are usually either an extension or the de just randomly crashes sometimes.
I think KDE devs are of the same opinions about layer-shell. There was also talk about restricting what kind of windows can be created with this protocol so that fullscreen overlays are not possible (because they can be abused for nefarious purposes). Not sure if it was implemented.
There was also talk about restricting what kind of windows can be created with this protocol so that fullscreen overlays are not possible (because they can be abused for nefarious purposes). Not sure if it was implemented.
A permission system, similar do Android’s “Allow to appear on top?” is the actual solution to that problem. Disclaimer: No idea if anybody (KDE or otherwise) implemented it.
I suppose. Though there still needs to a user-friendly mechanism to disable such overlay once it’s active, in case overlay blocks all interactions with the OS (intentionally or not).
Though there still needs to a user-friendly mechanism to disable such overlay once it’s active
Turn off the computer, log in as another user and uninstall.
in case overlay blocks all interactions with the OS (intentionally or not).
Well, for X11 there was a transparent lock screen whose entire point was to block all OS interactions until you entered the password. https://github.com/leonnnn/pyxtrlock
Obviously, a user friendly way (other than uninstalling from another user account) defeats the purpose.
Yeah but all the while people were yelling at them saying, “no, that’s my use-case you morons.” Turns out that when people have a use-case, they will come up with ways to carry on doing it even if you tell them really sternly that it’s for their own good that they don’t use their computers that way.
Yeah, it’s almost as if people SHOULD have the freedom for doing ANYTHING they want with their computers!
I sincerely hate Wayland and GNOME because of that. I want fucking control of my device, that’s the whole point why I threw the fuck up Microslop Winbugs in the first place.
At the same time I wanted untrusted app to not be able to do that because I cannot vet every app source code nor can I just not do my development work on sometimes arcane chinese linux build tools. It’s almost as if having choices is why we have Wayland and X. Dev moving away from X is not the fault of wayland. Even then, wayland has a way to implement extension for DE specific need giving user more choice if the DE developer deems that feature is needed. Wow, would you look at that. Choices. I can have my use case covered and so does yours.
Yeah I also don’t know how it works currently but screen sharing already has this system, any app trying to screen share gives you a popup to confirm what monitor/app you want to share and I think overlays could just use that exact system.
the GNOME maintainers would’ve ripped a huge fart, sniffed it and said “usecase??” while closing the issue, as they’ve done for years.
This issue was opened in April 2019, over the years listing various use cases and the reply was always “Make a Gnome extension”. Gnome’s Mutter is the only non-edge case Wayland compositor not to support this feature: https://wayland.app/protocols/wlr-layer-shell-unstable-v1#compositor-support (and Cage’s use case is to provide a kiosk, so that feature is probably not supported because of that specific reason and for such very specific cases it’s understandable)
There’s tons of ways they could’ve approached this instead of simply saying it’s not a valid usecase.
And it’s not how it currently works anyway. I stumbled upon this issue because the games would simple launch on the first enumerated monitor. Not the primary and not the active - the first port on my videocard.
The argument there is that it’s not a Wayland issue, but a compositor one I believe. And reading through it, I don’t think he’s necessarily wrong either.
Right, Apple calls this the active workspace which I think makes sense.
I come from Apple land and am settling in to Linux slowly, I don’t know any id the APIs, but I did try to make a Gnome app and found it an unusable stupid situation.
Sebastian needs to look at Apple’s AppKit frameworks.
Pretty much every app specifies its desired settings, which the OS (including the compositor) can override or manage correctly. They’re not a given in the API (see anything that says xWillY in their API pattern).
Further, macOS uses active workspace and auxiliary instead of primary, that works well. Instead of bike shedding the wording this could be discussed in good faith.
Now, I only know mac programming at this level, I don’t know if Wayland is similar, but it looks like there are established patterns for this, and how to deal with same sized displays, and the presentation software examples wanting to use auxiliary display for presentation vs speaker notes.
the GNOME maintainers would’ve ripped a huge fart, sniffed it and said “usecase??” while closing the issue, as they’ve done for years.
This, so much this. It was the exact same answer I got when I criticized that Gnome somehow managed to screw up screen mirroring - it is impossible to mirror two out of multiple screens, either you mirror all of them or none of them. Such a fundamentally basic feature we already had 20+ years ago, and they designed it away.
Or wallpapers. Guess how you set different wallpapers for different screens. …you can’t.
I don’t know what’s up with Gnome or why they are like this, but the way they caused a whole new DE again (Cosmic) and KDE outright leaving them in the dust they are on the best way towards obscurity.
If you think about Gnome in terms of it targeting some corporate client who cares a whole lot about screen lock, permissions, authentication against some corporate backend, etc, and not at all about a power user running around on their own, then that is one way that can explain why they do what they do. As an example it would be great for a business that needed something one step above a kiosk (maybe like a call center?) I’d love to walk into a DMV or bank and see all the computers running Gnome with a custom app that does all the personal information. That’d be way better than seeing someone flip tabs from their facebook to handle some financial transaction with Windows/Chrome.
The terminal is pretty nice with fonts and scaling, etc, but I don’t know how people use Gnome without the extensions to add back real menus and a program toolbar.
In my experience (admittedly a couple years back) Gnome is horrible for kiosk-style systems. There’s little to no builtin support for basic requirements like hiding the top bar while in non-fullscreen-mode. While there are some plugins, the scripting API is unstable, so plugins might break with any update.
I’d have far more confidence choosing KDE, though a more usecase-specific DM is better.
Sigh more gnome bullshut. It’s unfortunate because I like how it looks. Can’t wait for cosmic to be fleshed out
I use GNOME because for me KDE somehow always surfaces the small little annoying bugs (at least on my hardware). But I try every couple of years hoping I can finally switch.
This is my experience with KDE as well, dating back to 2007 and KDE3.
Yeah I’ve definitely had a buggier experience on kde than gnome. My only gnome “bugs” are usually either an extension or the de just randomly crashes sometimes.
I think KDE devs are of the same opinions about layer-shell. There was also talk about restricting what kind of windows can be created with this protocol so that fullscreen overlays are not possible (because they can be abused for nefarious purposes). Not sure if it was implemented.
A permission system, similar do Android’s “Allow to appear on top?” is the actual solution to that problem. Disclaimer: No idea if anybody (KDE or otherwise) implemented it.
I suppose. Though there still needs to a user-friendly mechanism to disable such overlay once it’s active, in case overlay blocks all interactions with the OS (intentionally or not).
Turn off the computer, log in as another user and uninstall.
Well, for X11 there was a transparent lock screen whose entire point was to block all OS interactions until you entered the password. https://github.com/leonnnn/pyxtrlock
Obviously, a user friendly way (other than uninstalling from another user account) defeats the purpose.
Preventing tbird-party apps from being able to do this was kinda one of the selling points of Wayland.
What about first-party apps? What about letting me do what I want with my computer?
Yeah but all the while people were yelling at them saying, “no, that’s my use-case you morons.” Turns out that when people have a use-case, they will come up with ways to carry on doing it even if you tell them really sternly that it’s for their own good that they don’t use their computers that way.
Yeah, it’s almost as if people SHOULD have the freedom for doing ANYTHING they want with their computers!
I sincerely hate Wayland and GNOME because of that. I want fucking control of my device, that’s the whole point why I threw the fuck up Microslop Winbugs in the first place.
At the same time I wanted untrusted app to not be able to do that because I cannot vet every app source code nor can I just not do my development work on sometimes arcane chinese linux build tools. It’s almost as if having choices is why we have Wayland and X. Dev moving away from X is not the fault of wayland. Even then, wayland has a way to implement extension for DE specific need giving user more choice if the DE developer deems that feature is needed. Wow, would you look at that. Choices. I can have my use case covered and so does yours.
Meanwhile infantilizing users, for sure.
Yeah I also don’t know how it works currently but screen sharing already has this system, any app trying to screen share gives you a popup to confirm what monitor/app you want to share and I think overlays could just use that exact system.
Damn. I WANT full screen overlays because Borderless Window doesn’t work for half the games I’ve tried
That’s against the user’s freedoms, so if they do, I’ll going to fucking boycott them.
That’s tivoization.
This issue was opened in April 2019, over the years listing various use cases and the reply was always “Make a Gnome extension”. Gnome’s Mutter is the only non-edge case Wayland compositor not to support this feature: https://wayland.app/protocols/wlr-layer-shell-unstable-v1#compositor-support (and Cage’s use case is to provide a kiosk, so that feature is probably not supported because of that specific reason and for such very specific cases it’s understandable)
My pet peeve is this one: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/wayland/wayland-protocols/-/work_items/179#note_2965559
(and yes, that’s once again our dear friend Sebastian from the screenshot above)
removes possibility for user to choose
wat?!
I mean. I kinda agree with him :p
If I’m on display2 and launch a game, maybe i wanted it there.
There’s tons of ways they could’ve approached this instead of simply saying it’s not a valid usecase. And it’s not how it currently works anyway. I stumbled upon this issue because the games would simple launch on the first enumerated monitor. Not the primary and not the active - the first port on my videocard.
The argument there is that it’s not a Wayland issue, but a compositor one I believe. And reading through it, I don’t think he’s necessarily wrong either.
Right, Apple calls this the active workspace which I think makes sense.
I come from Apple land and am settling in to Linux slowly, I don’t know any id the APIs, but I did try to make a Gnome app and found it an unusable stupid situation.
Sebastian needs to look at Apple’s AppKit frameworks.
Pretty much every app specifies its desired settings, which the OS (including the compositor) can override or manage correctly. They’re not a given in the API (see anything that says
xWillYin their API pattern).Further, macOS uses active workspace and auxiliary instead of primary, that works well. Instead of bike shedding the wording this could be discussed in good faith.
Now, I only know mac programming at this level, I don’t know if Wayland is similar, but it looks like there are established patterns for this, and how to deal with same sized displays, and the presentation software examples wanting to use auxiliary display for presentation vs speaker notes.