I don’t really consider the hammer and sickle to be more “right-wing.” It’s the symbol of Marxism-Leninism, of the unity of the working classes, the proletariat and peasantry. I’m a Marxist-Leninist, so the hammer and sickle represents me as well. Once you move onto anti-capitalism, I don’t think it makes much sense to compare in terms of left and right relationally, because it implies that that’s even a spectrum. There’s more and less idealist and materialist, more and less utopian and scientific, but left and right as comparisons lose meaning.
The USSR was already socialist, the state didn’t get in the way so much as the siege economy ran into problems when needing to develop light industry in the recovery period after World War II. Ideally, they would have been able to properly utilize markets in underdeveloped industry and keep them under the control of the state, rather than letting black markets crop up out of sight because the material basis of markets still existed. This black market led to the rise of a bourgeois class, combined with a weakened CPSU, combined with decades of trying to keep up militarily with the west and draining economic resources.
economically wise, yep, but it still had police and jails, the state still existed by coercing itself into the public.
they changed the authoritarian capitalist system for another one. Wether or not it was an improvement is such an annoying conversation i beg not to have it.
but I think we can still agree that the USSR was not the end goal of socialism. there was still progress to be done (definitely not returning to oligarch capitalism, that’s the opposite)
You can’t really abolish the state without a fully collectivized global system. They traded a dictatorship of capital to a dictatorship of the working class, which meant all the state structures necessary to protect the socialist system against rollback (until they failed). I maintain that the state itself was never an obstacle to progress, but instead the difficulties with progressing from siege economy to higher developments of socialism.
I don’t really consider the hammer and sickle to be more “right-wing.” It’s the symbol of Marxism-Leninism, of the unity of the working classes, the proletariat and peasantry. I’m a Marxist-Leninist, so the hammer and sickle represents me as well. Once you move onto anti-capitalism, I don’t think it makes much sense to compare in terms of left and right relationally, because it implies that that’s even a spectrum. There’s more and less idealist and materialist, more and less utopian and scientific, but left and right as comparisons lose meaning.
Fair enough, I still see it with USSR connotations, which was meant as a stepping stone to true socialism but states got in the way.
God fucking dammit, is a bugs Bunny meme, why am I diving into theory?
The USSR was already socialist, the state didn’t get in the way so much as the siege economy ran into problems when needing to develop light industry in the recovery period after World War II. Ideally, they would have been able to properly utilize markets in underdeveloped industry and keep them under the control of the state, rather than letting black markets crop up out of sight because the material basis of markets still existed. This black market led to the rise of a bourgeois class, combined with a weakened CPSU, combined with decades of trying to keep up militarily with the west and draining economic resources.
economically wise, yep, but it still had police and jails, the state still existed by coercing itself into the public.
they changed the authoritarian capitalist system for another one. Wether or not it was an improvement is such an annoying conversation i beg not to have it.
but I think we can still agree that the USSR was not the end goal of socialism. there was still progress to be done (definitely not returning to oligarch capitalism, that’s the opposite)
You can’t really abolish the state without a fully collectivized global system. They traded a dictatorship of capital to a dictatorship of the working class, which meant all the state structures necessary to protect the socialist system against rollback (until they failed). I maintain that the state itself was never an obstacle to progress, but instead the difficulties with progressing from siege economy to higher developments of socialism.
we agree on so much, with just enough subtle disagreeing points to keep going. please tell her you leave near me so we can go on a date
Haha, I appreciate it but I doubt my spouse would approve.
you’re not their bf, you’re our bf now
🤣