Glad he’s not a douche to those around him but he could give away billions and change so many lives for the better, but chooses to hang out on their big yacht.
My line in the sand is 1000 years of salary at median wage. That’s about 60k*1000 -> 60 million. Anything above that kept as personal wealth makes you an evil POS
That would be enough to live comfortably without working in most places on Earth. And in the ones where you can’t - well if nobody has more money than that, then there’s a limit to how expensive places can be.
I think it does depend a bit on how they made their billions, and I do separate someone like Newell (whose net worth is based on him owning at least half of Valve) from somebody whose net worth is more liquid/diversified. For Newell to give away billions, he’d need to sell off a large portion of his ownership of Valve, which would probably be bad for everyone. I have visions of private equity buying it and milking Steam for every last drop of value they could extract out of it.
It gets complicated because rich people can borrow against their ownership stakes or their stock, which is how I’m assuming Newell really funds everything. The easy way to solve it is probably to just tax the loans they take out so they aren’t dodging taxes, maybe at a higher rate than if they took an equivalent salary to incentivize them to go the salary route vs the borrowing route.
Otherwise you’d need to start saying no company can be worth more than $x, and anything bigger needs to be sold off or go public. But that gets back to the concerns about private equity, value extraction, and the continued enshittification of everything in the world as management tries to make the line perpetually go up.
TL;DR it’s just approximately what feels right + modified to make it easy to understand & share.
—-
I’m ok with “rich people”. Like someone should be able to invent something or make the right market bet or whatever to generate a lot of wealth. So the limit is above “good wage for every year of your life”. That’s around $200k * 80 = $16M as a lower bound. For today’s dollars.
I want the equation to be tied to median wage as well. This makes it scale with inflation so it becomes an easy equation to advocate for, if it was part of the zeitgeist then it wouldn’t need “updating” 20 years from now.
Then I just pad it. $16Mil is “what I feel is a good max” but going above that doesn’t make someone evil. So multiply it a couple times and you land near 1000 median salaries. So I round to that for the zeitgeist reasons.
From a different angle “1000 median salaries” is a number people can think about. $130Mil vs $175Mil feels like the same number. But people can visualize “an average dude working 1000 years straight”. For that same reason, it makes it more defensible. Maybe you think 500 years is better, or 200. But the real enemy aren’t the ones with an extra $30Mil you think they shouldn’t have. It’s the people with the extra $300,000Mil. 1000 years is both hard to argue with and also a clean cut off between “normal rich” and “oligarch criminal terrorist”
What you’re missing is that inequality is aggressively self-replicating.
You can’t have individual wealth accumulation and not end up with the Bezos and Musks of the world.
Whatever arbitrary line in the sand you want to draw, they’ll simply lobby and propagandise to erode it away, as they have successfully done for the last half century and change.
There are many reasons you should lump Gabe in with the evil billionaires. The most obvious is that all billionaires are evil.
He’s not responsible for all the worlds evils, but he is morally obligated to use his unfair influence in the world for the better. Again - morally obligated. And he’s not, not in the maximum capacity he could. Back when he soft retired he should have put nearly all his assets in a trust that gives him a reasonable annual stipend and put’s the rest towards a charitable foundation. I don’t care if he chairs it but him floating around in a small-town-on-water makes him evil.
You care about child labor. As one simple example, he could build a factory in any country with good labor laws and sell products at a loss. He could throw away millions on this venture that he knows will never generate profit only to reduce the profit motive for other countries to continue abusing their population. There are better ways to do good - this is just one easy example.
His yachts are purpose modified to do actual scientific marine research. He is contributing to humanity. It’s just not something that people consider important.
Billionaires should not exist
Including Gabe.
Glad he’s not a douche to those around him but he could give away billions and change so many lives for the better, but chooses to hang out on their big yacht.
My line in the sand is 1000 years of salary at median wage. That’s about 60k*1000 -> 60 million. Anything above that kept as personal wealth makes you an evil POS
Since Valve is a private company, it’s unknown how much income he has.
Also, median wage on earth is not 60k. It’s about 3k (purchase power parity dollars), so your limit would be 3 million.
That would be enough to live comfortably without working in most places on Earth. And in the ones where you can’t - well if nobody has more money than that, then there’s a limit to how expensive places can be.
I think it does depend a bit on how they made their billions, and I do separate someone like Newell (whose net worth is based on him owning at least half of Valve) from somebody whose net worth is more liquid/diversified. For Newell to give away billions, he’d need to sell off a large portion of his ownership of Valve, which would probably be bad for everyone. I have visions of private equity buying it and milking Steam for every last drop of value they could extract out of it.
It gets complicated because rich people can borrow against their ownership stakes or their stock, which is how I’m assuming Newell really funds everything. The easy way to solve it is probably to just tax the loans they take out so they aren’t dodging taxes, maybe at a higher rate than if they took an equivalent salary to incentivize them to go the salary route vs the borrowing route.
Otherwise you’d need to start saying no company can be worth more than $x, and anything bigger needs to be sold off or go public. But that gets back to the concerns about private equity, value extraction, and the continued enshittification of everything in the world as management tries to make the line perpetually go up.
1000 still feels like a lot. Any particular reason you picked that?
TL;DR it’s just approximately what feels right + modified to make it easy to understand & share.
—-
I’m ok with “rich people”. Like someone should be able to invent something or make the right market bet or whatever to generate a lot of wealth. So the limit is above “good wage for every year of your life”. That’s around $200k * 80 = $16M as a lower bound. For today’s dollars.
I want the equation to be tied to median wage as well. This makes it scale with inflation so it becomes an easy equation to advocate for, if it was part of the zeitgeist then it wouldn’t need “updating” 20 years from now.
Then I just pad it. $16Mil is “what I feel is a good max” but going above that doesn’t make someone evil. So multiply it a couple times and you land near 1000 median salaries. So I round to that for the zeitgeist reasons.
From a different angle “1000 median salaries” is a number people can think about. $130Mil vs $175Mil feels like the same number. But people can visualize “an average dude working 1000 years straight”. For that same reason, it makes it more defensible. Maybe you think 500 years is better, or 200. But the real enemy aren’t the ones with an extra $30Mil you think they shouldn’t have. It’s the people with the extra $300,000Mil. 1000 years is both hard to argue with and also a clean cut off between “normal rich” and “oligarch criminal terrorist”
I see. Thanks for the explanation!
With 60 million you’re plenty rich but can’t really influence politics. I always had 50 million in mind as being OK.
Depends. Certainly enough to influence local politics.
What you’re missing is that inequality is aggressively self-replicating.
You can’t have individual wealth accumulation and not end up with the Bezos and Musks of the world.
Whatever arbitrary line in the sand you want to draw, they’ll simply lobby and propagandise to erode it away, as they have successfully done for the last half century and change.
yea we know but let’s not bundle the evil billionaires that profit off child labor, with the ones that treat their employees and company greatly.
all we would achieve is alienating everyone with money from something they may otherwise contribute towards with their literal billions
There are many reasons you should lump Gabe in with the evil billionaires. The most obvious is that all billionaires are evil.
He’s not responsible for all the worlds evils, but he is morally obligated to use his unfair influence in the world for the better. Again - morally obligated. And he’s not, not in the maximum capacity he could. Back when he soft retired he should have put nearly all his assets in a trust that gives him a reasonable annual stipend and put’s the rest towards a charitable foundation. I don’t care if he chairs it but him floating around in a small-town-on-water makes him evil.
You care about child labor. As one simple example, he could build a factory in any country with good labor laws and sell products at a loss. He could throw away millions on this venture that he knows will never generate profit only to reduce the profit motive for other countries to continue abusing their population. There are better ways to do good - this is just one easy example.
His yachts are purpose modified to do actual scientific marine research. He is contributing to humanity. It’s just not something that people consider important.
Why not sell the yacht and purchase 30 vessels designed to optimize for research?
His recent yacht sleeps 55 people. Are you under the impression he has 30+ researchers on his yacht?
Yeah, that’s exactly what they were hired for.
No, lets not have billionaires.