• 0 Posts
  • 340 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 4th, 2024

help-circle





  • I think this is a logical conclusion if one believes “brainwashing” on mass is a thing for an explanation of the bourgoisie proleteriat; it will lead to a biolgical determinist rationale for resistance to being “unbrainwashed” and then it’s a short hop from that to eugenicism echoing essentially fascist sentiments.

    Instead consider a more dialectical materialist take:

    https://redsails.org/masses-elites-and-rebels/

    Ie narratives as a social license for bigotry along imperialist and settler colonial lines because at some level that individual benefits from those material conditions. The material always come before the idea.

    (There’s all sorts of other problems with yugopnik’s take - like folks with learning difficulties who don’t lean right wing, removing the agency of the fascist, using ablism to explain fascism, where these Nietzschean takes of the untermenschen comes from, mechanical vs dialectical materialism etc etc)














  • Nah he’s taking the piss (ie sardonic/ironic) given his whole angle (see below).

    Doesn’t mean he’s always right (though his irony here in this is example is just generally correct) or even a scientific socialist given his anti-russian and anti-chinese rhetoric echoing imperial talking points (even anti-maduro stuff in the past regarding elections, from what I recall).

    But he is otherwise quite anti-west including holding most westerners (especially USAmericans) accountable for the crimes of their countries. Which is why he sometimes comes off sounding correct because even if you don’t know a thing about socialism or imperialism, being anti-western can sometimes be not too bad an heuristic on politics given how awful the West is and the commanding heights of imperialism being the US.

    He openly admits that his viewers have a parasocial relationship with youtubers, that his channel isn’t some revolutionary avenue, and that he is happy to make money making easy dunks such as on pro-zionists. Some of the videos on his main channel can be educational (such as on Nazi Germany’s inspiration from the US with manifest Destiny and Lebensraum).

    But he is also a good example that if one wants to extend their political educstion beyond BE level of anti-western imperialism then self claimed marxists better get to grips of prodhounism, dialectical materialism and start reading broadly beyond Settlers*.

    *= has no real grounded theory of political economy on why the global labour aristocracy / bourgoisie proleteriat also includes people of colour, especially in the West. It’s great book to introduce someone how bad the history of white western proleteriat is but then hits its limitations quickly.


  • Thanks for the share!

    I have yet to read the full paper but that abstract and a cursory purview is not promising of the validity of the conclusions the paper is implying regarding Covid-19 vaccinations; there appears to be no meaty analysis of:

    • how the populations studied aren’t reflecting increasingly diminished access to healthcare,
    • that confirming a vaccination is so much easier than a recent or historical covid-19 infection
    • there are no known pathognomic symptoms of COVID-19 other than maybe anosmia that distinguish from other viral illnesses, and there is no method of diagnosing a subclinical covid-19 infection noted in each of those patients that got a vaccine and then a subsequent cancer
    • and all of the above is on the background of known effects of COVID-19 pathophysiology on the immune system, especially T-cell mediated pathways

    I was interested initially because of potential analysis on mRNA vaccines. The most curious thing for me on the paper is potential site injection cancers and I have to read it in more detail but superificially the way they seem to explain it appears to be a bit shoddily done and therefore gets me questioning its validity.