Judge Analisa Torres, of the Southern District of New York, authorized on November 16 that certain annexes and parts of the material presented by the defense of the constitutional president of Venezuela, Nicolás Maduro, be sealed , although the memorandum that supports the request for sovereign immunity is already circulating in its redacted version.

The 72-page document, filed on November 9 by attorneys Barry J. Pollack and Anna Estevao, requests the dismissal “with prejudice” of the fifth superseding indictment , which would prevent the prosecution from refiling the charges. Its central argument is that “Mr. Maduro cannot be compelled to stand trial because he is protected by foreign sovereign immunity.”

To support this, the defense invokes the immunity of head of state , because Maduro “was the acting head of state of Venezuela when the government illegally kidnapped him,” and immunity for official acts , since the charges are based on what he allegedly did as a “high-ranking official of the Venezuelan government.”

Judge Torres took over the case after the death of Judge Alvin Hellerstein and has scheduled a hearing on sovereign immunity for December 17 .

A sitting president on the day of the kidnapping

According to the memorandum, the prosecution itself acknowledges that Maduro assumed the presidency through constitutional succession in 2013 and that, even after 2019, he continued to exercise “the powers of the Venezuelan presidency.” The defense argues that this status is sufficient for immunity, despite Washington’s designation of him as "illegitimate . "

The document recalls that the US government maintained direct contact with Maduro after the 2019 breakdown, including a meeting between special envoy Richard Grenell and Caracas in January 2025, and a telephone conversation with Donald Trump later that year.

At the United Nations, the General Assembly accepted the credentials of the Maduro government at every session since 2019. In December 2025, only Ecuador, Argentina, Peru and Paraguay joined the United States in its refusal.

Following the kidnapping on January 3 , the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice appointed Delcy Rodríguez as acting president without declaring the office vacant. Washington recognized her and re-established diplomatic relations , a stance the memorandum describes as “illogical at best ,” because Maduro appointed her vice president after the same elections that the United States does not recognize.

The defense maintains that immunity is measured on the day of arrest and that Venezuela never waived it. On January 5, before the United Nations Security Council , Ambassador Samuel Moncada denounced the kidnapping as a violation of the personal immunity of heads of state.

Charges based on acts of state

The second immunity protects officials for actions taken on behalf of the state. According to the document, the accusation does not attribute any private conduct to Maduro , and each charge relates to the positions he held as a member of parliament, foreign minister, vice president, and president.

Among the events cited by the Prosecutor’s Office are the sale of diplomatic passports when he was foreign minister, meetings with FARC leaders at the Miraflores Palace , and the creation of an Anti-Coup Command in a televised cabinet meeting.

The charge of conspiracy to commit torture , which the prosecution added on October 6, requires that the accused acted “under the law ,” meaning with public authority. The defense argues that by bringing this charge, the prosecution is acknowledging that Maduro acted as a state official .

An accusation that changed after the first claim

The defense had filed an initial motion for immunity on September 2 against the fourth indictment, which described Maduro as the ruler who “is now” the de facto leader of Venezuela. The fifth version, approved before the court ruled, changed it to say that he “was formerly” president.

According to the memo, the torture charge is based on “recycled accusations” and came more than nine months after the kidnapping. Maduro and Representative Cilia Flores , whose defense is also claiming immunity , pleaded not guilty to the new charges.

The lawyers ask the judge to rule according to her own criteria , without limiting herself to the Executive’s position, and they close their argument on presidential immunity with a comparison: “This country would not tolerate another country accusing our head of state of abuse of power in its national courts, much less kidnapping him to take him to its territory to face those charges.”

  • loathsome dongeater@lemmygrad.mlM
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    21
    ·
    2 days ago

    A 92 yo judge was hearing the case and he died during the proceedings. Very cool. Do they not have retirement ages over there for judges?

    • Red_Scare [he/him]@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      edit-2
      1 day ago

      I wish I could’ve got into judging circles, cause the trouble with being a miner, as soon as you’re too old and tired and ill and sick and stupid to do your job properly you have to go, but the very opposite applies with the judges. So all in all, I’d rather have been a judge than a miner, cause I’ve always been after the trappings of great luxury. Have always fancied 'em. Yet I got hold of the trappings of great poverty. I got hold of the wrong load of trappings, and a rotten load of old trappings that is.

      (I’ve heard Peter Cook was a terrible human but this sketch is still close to my heart: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ofUZNynYXzM)

    • AliOski@feddit.nl
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      12
      ·
      2 days ago

      Well… people that really enjoy their job often refuse to go into retirement until they physically/mentally cannot handle it anymore. Now, being a judge is not that physical, it just requires that you can read, hear, speak and think properly…

      • loathsome dongeater@lemmygrad.mlM
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        14
        ·
        edit-2
        2 days ago

        I meant a legally mandated retirement age like we have here in India. Not that it does much good but at least there is a rationale behind it. Judges don’t die in 9ffice at least.

        • AliOski@feddit.nl
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          arrow-down
          8
          ·
          2 days ago

          I dont know whether that pro is worth the cons. Good judges are hard to come by, and it already takes way too long for most cases to finally start due to backlogs. Any capable person should be allowed or even stimulated to stay a judge. For the one time when a case is interrupted due to a judge dying, they make up for it due to the fact they helped out with many cases up until that point.

            • AliOski@feddit.nl
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              1 day ago

              Why shouldn’t they, provided their mind is still crystal clear? Most world leaders are pushing 80.

              It is just with matters that involve modern technology that I think older people have difficulty with. I wouldn’t want a 90 year old presiding over a case against big social media corporations for instance, but international politics/criminal cases, those haven’t changed for the last couple thousands of years.

              • LocalAreaMan [he/him]@hexbear.net
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                6
                ·
                1 day ago

                But overthrowing a democracy and stealing oil is very straightforward as it is timeless, something any crypt keeper could get their atrophied brain around. 🧐For thousands of years…🤤

                harold-manic