• burlemarx@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    16 hours ago

    To be fair, making a revolution succeed and last is a tremendous feat, so I’m not surprised that most revolutions and revolutionary groups failed in the past. This is one of the reason why the Russian revolution is so significant.

    But tbf, the tactics used in Cuba, Vietnam, Yugoslavia, Korea and China were different from the Bolsheviks. And the Yugoslavia model is the closest thing we have to a worker council and worker self-management model, so you could say that Yugoslavia followed a left-com path, even though, technically, that wouldn’t be true.

    • Red_Scare [he/him]@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      9
      ·
      15 hours ago

      Tito was a left-com cause unlike Bolsheviks he had councils, and if you don’t reproduce Bolshevik revolutionary tactics to the letter your revolution isn’t Marxist-Leninist, you heard it here first folks!

      Hint, look up what the word soviet means.

      • burlemarx@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        7
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        edit-2
        7 hours ago

        I know you are trolling me, but as I said, Tito wasn’t really a left-com, even though the program he championed post war was one of worker self management, one of the positions defended by left coms.

        I know what are the Soviets, but the Soviets were not the units that dictate production in the USSR. Production was controlled by the GOSPLAN, specially after the 30s.

        But I’m not speaking which economic model was better. Yugoslavia model had their own issues, and it’s one of the socialist experiences that had a higher than average unemployment.

        But what I wanted to emphasize is that revolutions are won by multiple factors and it’s not a coincidence that different revolutions had different strategies/tactics. The Bolsheviks were superb in their strategy and we give them praise for this, and I genuinely love Lenin’s book about left wing communism, which is one that I often cite to my ML comrades, and one that is extremely relevant in the current times. However, what I want to emphasize that we can’t look at ML strategies and tactics in the Russian Revolution like a cookbook.

        Edit: and one thing I forgot to add, declaring oneself as a ML doesn’t make you immediately right.

        • Red_Scare [he/him]@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          8
          ·
          10 hours ago

          I’ll be honest I know very little about left communism. I thought it can’t really be decoupled from idealistic criticism of actually existing socialist states, e.g. accusations that Lenin was a counter-revolutionary for limiting the role of early Soviets and centralising the power in the hands of the party, and ignoring the conditions in which those decisions were made. Basically same as anarchist grievances, except anarchists have done some real organising and work on the ground like mutual help etc. So it’s weird to hear accusations of leftist infighting when left communism seems to only have ever done that.

          When people here poke fun at left coms, I don’t think they are against worker self management, let alone councils / soviets, which are entirely compatible with Marxism-Leninism. I think it’s more a rejection of idealistic conception of revolution where it’s supposed to immediately emancipate the workers and give them complete control of the country when in reality you need a vanguard party to defend the revolution.

          For the same reason I wouldn’t call Tito a left com, workers had some measure of economic control of their enterprises but the political power was still in the hands of the party. Even Khrushchev attempted to strengthen the Soviets (unsuccessfully) but the central role of the party was never in question. While for left coms, the party can’t rule “in the name” of the workers, the worker councils are supposed to directly control the country (I think? Again, never really cared enough to look deeper into this).

          • burlemarx@lemmygrad.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            3
            arrow-down
            1
            ·
            5 hours ago

            I think we need to differentiate between left coms through the different historical period. When Lenin criticized left coms in Germany, they were advocating towards worker councils, reject working with reactionary unions, and reject parliamentarism. This happened just after the split among the SPD and after Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht deaths at the the Freikorps, and the defeat of the 1919 uprising.

            So, the leftcoms were not acting out of “idealism”. They suffered a crushing defeat at the hands of the SPD, many of their leaders dead, many people imprisoned, many of their members expelled from the SPD while the petit bourgeois leadership of the SPD (namely Friedrich Revert) just betrayed them all. So they wanted to reject the other more legal forms of struggle in name of a more radical and revolutionary one.

            But this is why I think Lenin’s criticism was so important. They advised them to not to let go of the reactionary unions, not to let go of parliamentary methods and the reason for this is simple, without a support of the majority of the working class, going towards illegal methods of struggle would simply result in their defeat.

            Only later that left coms, after fleeing from Germany, were known for criticizing the one-party government of the Bolsheviks. But honestly I think this is more out of spite for their defeat and lack of support in the international.

            So, yes, leftcoms today are just anti-USSR socialist sympathizers. But left come at their time were genuinely trying to organize and achieve revolution, even with misguided tactics and strategy. So I don’t think it’s fair to characterize people back then as idealists.

            And don’t forget that MLs today that don’t do any revolution are the new left coms today, with misguided political lines, strategy and tactics. Cosplaying revolutionaries do not make any of us superior to the people who were defeated back then.

    • freagle@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      34
      ·
      2 days ago

      The cause is helped by accurate analysis of reality. Left communism is relative movement that critiques a movement for communism for not being moral/ideal enough. Informing people inclined to such a movement that this position has never produced a successful revolution is actually quite helpful to the cause. We need to disabuse the proletariat of the illusions that cause them to split from the vanguard so that they can empower the mass movement instead of disempower it

      • 3scene@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        arrow-down
        15
        ·
        2 days ago

        Whilst I appreciate the comment, taking the view that ‘do not think X else it will not lead to Y’ is unhelpful and a gross simplification, by this it would be true to say that stalinism is doomed to fail. It also reads that in order for communism to be successful it must be immoral by using your own comment. This community is a wondrous place, but the memes channel usually punches left and doesnt punch right.

          • 3scene@lemmygrad.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            arrow-down
            11
            ·
            1 day ago

            As we speak there is a lovely back and forth regarding the fall of the USSR, where people have characterised the differences between sino/soviet in international relations, and like others that refer to the period of relations with other states and revolutions under stalin which I was shorthanding as stalinism- is that a mischaracterization?

        • freagle@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          23
          ·
          2 days ago

          Stalinism, which doesn’t really exist afaik, is either MLism, which has succeeded in completing revolutions multiple times, or is something describing Stalin’s personal tactics for protecting the revolution, which did fail.

          If every ML revolution failed, then it would be correct that MLism would be an ineffective theory of liberation. But MLism has succeeded multiple times and Left Communism has only ever failed to produce a revolution. It has never had a chance to sustain a revolution because it never launched one.

          Sure, go ahead, try to be a Left Comm and build a revolution. No one can stop you, but there’s no reason we can’t resist the Left Comm program of attacking MList revolutionary movements. The only revolution that can succeed is the one that defend itself.

          • 3scene@lemmygrad.ml
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            2
            arrow-down
            12
            ·
            1 day ago

            It is interesting that a political theory that hasn’t been especially openly discussed since the first world war, dying along with Luxemborg, isn’t tested or debated openly to determine if it can fit with the material conditions and the people of today. We are violently campist, and refuse to pick and choose or adapt accorsing, seemingly we must to take the approach of the october revolution or nothing else. What worked for China isnt what will work foe Venezuela, and if all revolutions must look the same we really are doomed to fail and break our backs on the same wheels. The party charty of '29 declared anything that was not ML as an enemy, in a world without nuance there are no heavily relations between people, the CCP would not be able to neighbor the SRV.

            • freagle@lemmy.ml
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              11
              ·
              17 hours ago

              We also don’t debate phlogiston or humors theory. You are confused. Every revolution has looked different, every single one. But the only ones that succeeded were ML revolutions. Granted, ML revolutions also failed, but only ML revolutions have succeeded.

              What do you do with that data? How does one incorporate the lessons of history into our programs for the future? You want to debate Left Communism? Then debate it with other Left Communists. Don’t expect anyone who disagrees with you to waste time developing a theory for something that has never worked. The critique is their contribution. If you can’t defend your ideas internally amongst people sympathetic to your position, then you’re not going to be able to defend it against people who are skeptical or hostile and you certainly won’t make any real world change.

              It is not campist to have a heliocentric model of the universe. It is not campist to run your baseball team with a moneyball strategy. It is not campist to focus on things that have been historically shown to work and to defend your project against people who are more concerned with ideology than effectiveness.

              Also, the Communist Party of China is the appropriate name of the party, not the Chinese Communist Party. This would follow the naming scheme of all Communist parties. Further, the CPC is the party and the PRC is the state. The Vietnamese equivalent would be the CPV (Communist Party of Vietnam) and not the VCP (Vietnamese Communist Party).