RSS Bot@lemmy.bestiver.seBM to Hacker News@lemmy.bestiver.seEnglish · 1 month agoAdobe Creative Suite Cleanroom Ported to Rustgithub.comexternal-linkmessage-square4linkfedilinkarrow-up12arrow-down12file-textcross-posted to: opensource@programming.devopensource@lemmy.ml
arrow-up10arrow-down1external-linkAdobe Creative Suite Cleanroom Ported to Rustgithub.comRSS Bot@lemmy.bestiver.seBM to Hacker News@lemmy.bestiver.seEnglish · 1 month agomessage-square4linkfedilinkfile-textcross-posted to: opensource@programming.devopensource@lemmy.ml
minus-squareXyre@lemmus.orglinkfedilinkEnglisharrow-up4·1 month agoHow does vibe-coding an app equate to a clean-room implementation?
minus-squareTragicNotCute@lemmy.worldlinkfedilinkEnglisharrow-up1·1 month agoIt’s a clean room port because presumably they didn’t decompile or have access to the code. Edit: From the site: Clean-room: implemented from public specs and observed behaviour only. No proprietary code, shaders or assets.
minus-squareXyre@lemmus.orglinkfedilinkEnglisharrow-up4·1 month agoRight, but unless you can prove the provenance of the training data for the model it violates the spirit of clean-room design no?
minus-squareokwhateverdude@lemmy.worldlinkfedilinkEnglisharrow-up3·1 month agoIf it trained on the leaked sources, you’re correct. More likely is that there are already many open source tools that mimic adobe’s tools already. So the request could be for photoshop feature X, but you get laundered GIMP for X instead.
How does vibe-coding an app equate to a clean-room implementation?
It’s a clean room port because presumably they didn’t decompile or have access to the code.
Edit:
From the site:
Right, but unless you can prove the provenance of the training data for the model it violates the spirit of clean-room design no?
If it trained on the leaked sources, you’re correct. More likely is that there are already many open source tools that mimic adobe’s tools already. So the request could be for photoshop feature X, but you get laundered GIMP for X instead.