Essentially he thinks that, because surveillance is so powerful, and because of 21st-century advancements in the military, there is no way that a socialist uprising could happen, if any at all. The news already does a good job of showing that the US has this new incredible surveillance tech!! and could send these brand new, ultra-powerful drones to bomb you!! and it’s all powered by really smart algorithms that can show all your history!!. They are very opaque about how to stop it, and it seems almost like a form of state-terrorism where the US shows its most freitening new technology to the media so that the people feel helpless, thus disinclined to start groups critical of the government. It seems that there is a strain where people like my friend see changing material conditions, and interpret the change as shutting off revolutionary potential once and for all.

I really want to know what you guys think. It really feeds into a lot of Anarchist notions to just leave alone the possibility of overthrow and tend to your own garden and write poems, or Liberal notions of simply voting because nothing else could possibly work.

  • UhhhDunkDunk@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    2 months ago

    Probably more complicated than a socialist uprising ‘succeeding’. I’m not entirely sure what that actually means. Solid point that the western intelligence apparatus is as sprawling as the west itself. And the state maintains a powerful monopoly on violence and the flow of information/propaganda. But the idea that somehow the US governemnt would be able to continue if its reality deteriorated into needing to drone strike its civilian population is kind of nonsensical.

    Occupying armies cannot really win a war only battles. And the scenerio I’m hearing brought up here is that threatening occupation would or does calm a populace- I’d offer it incites the opposite. And if the us army or whatever body you like actually becomes an overt occupier… There is no win game for the state, every success recruits more opposition. Other people have expressed these ideas way better than I could(and have used historical examples, someone did a great breakdown kind if based on Syria style collapse) but it seems like it is very difficult/impossible to maintain a society that occupies itself.

    Maybe, the idea of ciritcal mass of people not having a ‘minimal’ level of survivability, is more important. It seems like all successful revolutions occur when a state has meaningfully failed to provide a base level of material conditions. And it horrifically seems to be a level around what we’d consider as societal collapse(tzarist Russia, emperial China), that at such a point revolutionary conditions will occur- might not prevail (see the hundreds of uprisings that have already happened over US history), but it will happen. So, do you or your friend ever think those conditions could happen in the US? If so, a socialist revolution could totally happen(so could a non socialist revolution- gross. And I think that’s what the idea of a vanguard party is kind of about). I’d say if you can imagine a future where the US is failing to provide food for a state- you’re in the uprising is possible camp. Its all about those material conditions! Edit: added a ()