China’s exports of tomato paste to industry powerhouse Italy have collapsed this year after an outcry over alleged use of forced labour in Xinjiang and complaints about misleading origin labelling by some Italian companies.
The western Chinese region of Xinjiang dramatically increased tomato cultivation and processing in recent years, but slumping sales to Italy and other western European markets have left it sitting on a vast stockpile of unsold paste, industry analysts say.
Italian farming association Coldiretti has led a high-profile campaign to defend the national staple red fruit against an influx of Chinese paste costing less than half of that made from their farmers’ crops.
“This is an important victory,” said Francesco Mutti, chief executive of the eponymous maker of Italian tomato-based ingredients including passata, pulp and purée. “It is a very positive signal.”
Scrutiny of the tomato supply chain in Europe has heightened since some companies in Italy — the world’s largest exporter of finished tomato ingredients ready for consumers — were found to have mixed Chinese tomato paste into wares promoted as Italian.
[…]
Tomato News, which tracks the global processing industry and trade, estimates China has a stockpile of 600,000 to 700,000 tonnes of tomato paste — equivalent to roughly six months of its exports.
While China’s total tomato paste exports by volume fell 9 per cent year-on-year in the third quarter of 2025, sales to western EU countries dropped 67 per cent, and Italy’s purchases were down 76 per cent, Tomato News said.
“Clearly Europe has become a difficult place to export to,” said Martin Stilwell, president of Tomato News. Chinese customs data shows the value of processed tomato exports to Italy plunged to less than $13mn in the first nine months of 2025 from more than $75mn in the same period of last year.
[…]
China has turned Xinjiang, home to the mainly-Muslim Uyghur minority, into a low-cost, export-oriented tomato paste production hub spearheaded by large state companies, one of which is a subsidiary of the paramilitary Production and Construction Corps that helps run the region.
China processed 11mn tonnes of fresh tomatoes into paste in 2024, up from 4.8mn tonnes in 2021, according to Tomato News. With European demand collapsing, the Asian nation has more than halved the volume of the fruit processed to an expected 3.7mn tonnes this year, Stilwell said.
[…]
“They are struggling to sell, which explains why they have to cut back — otherwise they would merely be building inventory in China,” he said.
Xinjiang’s tomato industry has been dogged by allegations of use of forced Uyghur labour
[…]
The influx of Chinese tomato paste into Italy came under the spotlight in 2021 when the Carabinieri police raided a leading processing company and seized tonnes of canned tomato concentrate that included Chinese paste but was falsely labelled “100 per cent Italian”.
[…]
This is a battle won, sure, but let’s not assume the war is over. China will continue to force the Uyghur to make low-cost goods for export. That ‘business model’ is highly profitable for the suppressor as it earns money while keeping the population too busy and spread out to organise themselves.
And Italy will continue to farm its tomato fields with immigrant workers that live in slave-like coditions.
The immigrants in Italy definitly work under shitty conditions, but you cannot compare their lives with the Uyghur. First of all, the immigrants can leave (and work under equally shitty conditions somewhere else, sure), where as the Uyghur have no legal way of leaving their country. They are under heavy surveillance and speaking up about their shitty conditions can get them into serious trouble, unlike the immigrants in Italy who at most risk their job and housing (which is also a shitty position, sure - but a lot less scary as forcibly being taken to another labour camp to work even longer hours under even shittier conditions). I wouldn’t want to switch places with anyone from either group, but i would pick immigrants worker in Italy over forced labourer in Xinjiang any day.
I think there are also cases in which the working/living conditions of those migrants might be even worse. In general, I agree with you though. Just wanted to point out that it’s not all roses just because something is produced in Europe.
it’s not all roses just because something is produced in Europe.
I am aware, thanks
Just wanted to point out
What a surprise, almost thought i could leave a comment about something bad in China or Russia and not have an .ml user commenting about the bad things in Europe or US.
But let’s not fight because we seem to agree people deserve a decent live wherever they live and whoever they work for, voluntary or not, and i guess that matters most.
Funny, usually other .ml users tell me I should change instance, because I critize China or Russia.
But let’s not fight because we seem to agree people deserve a decent live wherever they live and whoever they work for, voluntary or not, and i guess that matters most.
Indeed, have a nice day!